With all of the current changes in education, we continue to want what is right for children. If we need to expect more then let's do that. If we need to give more time for students to learn, then lets be open to that.
After 3 days of looking at math through the lens of K-3 students and teachers I have certainly taken more than I have given. It was interesting to watch and listen as teachers who have already stretched themselves about as far as they can were asking for more. Asking to see what they could do because it is what their kids need. At the same time, it was humbling to watch the few who just were not open to new ideas. Instead of taking the opportunity to learn from a master they closed their minds (and opened their mouths) and decided they had everything figured out. Why were these teachers (who I do not know at all) so upset? It was hard not to overhear their side conversation about how their principal made the second grade team come, but not the third grade team. So instead of seeing this as an opportunity, note that their was a significant waiting list of others who would have been thankful to come, they chose to see this as an assignment. I hope their students are more receptive to their teaching, becauce rememeber that the students that walk through their door each day are told to come and get not choice as well.
Back to my real thinking of today though (sorry for the rant), these days reminded me of a short talk by Arthur Benjamin (who I do not know at all, but whose video on TED.com caught my eye some time back). Arthur Benjamin makes the case that we have the wrong target in math education. We view algebra and calculus as the most important math and thus we make that our target for students. He makes the case that most of us, except economists, engineers and mathematicians, really do not use or apply calculus in everyday life. However, what we could use more of is a deeper understanding of probability, statistics, and data. His talk is less than 5 minutes and can be found at www.ted.com (search Arthur Benjamin).
Mulligan Project
Thursday, July 29, 2010
Kathy Richardson Thoughts and Quotes
Just some of my notes that have stood out from the first three days learning from Kathy Richardson.
You do not have to be dynamic to be good and right.
Writing someone's name over and over does not mean that you know them any better. Writing facts again and again does not mean that you know what they mean any better. There is no meaning in the symbol. However, if you understand who the person is, eventually the symbol (their name) stands for all you know about that person. The same is true with mathematics. Eventually the symbols (the digits) come to be a reminder of what you know if teaching/learning is conceptual.
Sometimes in school kids learn that they are just supposed to say something or say anything at all.
If I can talk someone out of something, then they really do not know it.
If kids never see that larger numbers are made up of smaller numbers, they will always count. If a child does not internalize that 17 is 10 and 7 more or that 8 is 5 and 3, they will always need to count.
For young kids, numbers are adjectives, not nouns. Numbers describe something, so without that something, the numbers are abstract to the kid and since they are adjectives, the numbers just do not make sense to young children. So 3 is just a symbol, but 3 cookies is meaningful to young students. Therefore a child may be able to answer 3 cookies and 6 more cookies, but not be able to see 3+6.
In math we are more accepting of not understanding as long as you can solve the problem.
It does not matter that the answer is nonsense to you as long as you can do it.
This is much of how most of us were taught.
It is not mathematics if you do not understand the math you are doing.
We do not say that a student is reading if all they can do is say the words in the paragraph. to be reading, the student must be able to tell you what the paragraph meant.
Why is this not treated as the same truth in math?
You cannot tell how much a student knows by looking at answers only. How much do we know when a child only hands a paper in to us?
Children are often asked to work with ideas they do not understand, so they do what they are told (or think they are told) and give up all logic and sense making.
We need a change from, "I am a good teacher because my kids learn a lot and do well on tests." (illusions) to "I am a good teacher because I know what each student needs and I can push and support them with what they need." (core learning)
www.mathperspectives.com
www.didax.com
You do not have to be dynamic to be good and right.
Writing someone's name over and over does not mean that you know them any better. Writing facts again and again does not mean that you know what they mean any better. There is no meaning in the symbol. However, if you understand who the person is, eventually the symbol (their name) stands for all you know about that person. The same is true with mathematics. Eventually the symbols (the digits) come to be a reminder of what you know if teaching/learning is conceptual.
Sometimes in school kids learn that they are just supposed to say something or say anything at all.
If I can talk someone out of something, then they really do not know it.
If kids never see that larger numbers are made up of smaller numbers, they will always count. If a child does not internalize that 17 is 10 and 7 more or that 8 is 5 and 3, they will always need to count.
For young kids, numbers are adjectives, not nouns. Numbers describe something, so without that something, the numbers are abstract to the kid and since they are adjectives, the numbers just do not make sense to young children. So 3 is just a symbol, but 3 cookies is meaningful to young students. Therefore a child may be able to answer 3 cookies and 6 more cookies, but not be able to see 3+6.
In math we are more accepting of not understanding as long as you can solve the problem.
It does not matter that the answer is nonsense to you as long as you can do it.
This is much of how most of us were taught.
It is not mathematics if you do not understand the math you are doing.
We do not say that a student is reading if all they can do is say the words in the paragraph. to be reading, the student must be able to tell you what the paragraph meant.
Why is this not treated as the same truth in math?
You cannot tell how much a student knows by looking at answers only. How much do we know when a child only hands a paper in to us?
Children are often asked to work with ideas they do not understand, so they do what they are told (or think they are told) and give up all logic and sense making.
We need a change from, "I am a good teacher because my kids learn a lot and do well on tests." (illusions) to "I am a good teacher because I know what each student needs and I can push and support them with what they need." (core learning)
www.mathperspectives.com
www.didax.com
Wednesday, July 28, 2010
Kathy Richardson
The last two days I have had a chance to listen to and learn from an educator who just gets it. She brings to light many thoughts that I have had, but never been able to put words to. She makes the connection between what we have said and heard in literacy for years and math. I had heard that I would really enjoy listening to Kathy Richardson speak about young math learners. What I found was so much more. What she speaks to is the reason that so many students struggle in math. She gets to the heart of number sense and making learning conceptual. However, she does not rely on flashy materials or over the top antics. It is just about creating and environment where kids can be curious and giving them the right tasks where they can push themselves.
Thanks to Jeane Joyner, her team, and Meredith College for providing this opportunity to so many of us.
www.mathperspectives.com
www.didax.com
Thanks to Jeane Joyner, her team, and Meredith College for providing this opportunity to so many of us.
www.mathperspectives.com
www.didax.com
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)